New Brunswick’s $250,000 problem

New Brunswick has 59% fewer people who earn $200,000 per year and 63% fewer people who earn $250,00 per year compared to Canada as a whole.

To put that into some kind of context, you would have to look far and wide to find any major social, demographic or economic indicator where New Brunswick had a 60% spread with the rest of Canada.  Not literacy, education, poverty or health outcomes.  Not median income or any other main economic indicator.

But when it comes to ‘high’ income earners we have a huge gap.  And the gap is widening at least at the highest level.  In the past five years the national growth rate of those earning $250,000 was 50% faster than New Brunswick.

Does this matter?   Well, I think it does.  By my estimate just getting to the national average for higher income earners would add some $200 million in provincial government tax revenues each year.  And that is grossly understated because it doesn’t account for other sources of tax revenue that would be derived from the economic activity generated by those high income earners (I only looked at the direct taxes off the additional personal income).  In other words it pushes the tax burden down the income pyramid.

Now let me be clear.  If the price to get more higher income earners means less income for those lower in the income pyramid (i.e. creating more inequality) – that is not acceptable.  But I am talking about generating relatively high incomes from creating new wealth from entrepreneurial activity, risk taking and hard work.

How do we do that?  We need more ambitious entrepreneurs looking to build markets outside New Brunswick and we need world class companies willing to step outside their comfort zone and take risk.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on New Brunswick’s $250,000 problem

Energy and mining export values down, gypsum, aquaculture and peanut butter up

A quick look at the international export data for the first four months of 2016 reveals that the value of energy-related exports is down significantly this year so far. The total value of refined petroleum exports, gas exports (mostly LNG) and NB Power exports is down by $869 million this year so far. You have to be careful with this, however, as the lost ‘value from refined petroleum exports could be upstream as the value of oil and gas imports is down by $636 million during the same period.  The decline in Canaport exports to New England is likely due to the mild winter.

Other decliners including non-metallic minerals (potash) – no surprise there – and the rest of the declines are quite marginal and could be due more to currency fluctuations than production declines.

International merchandise exports – Biggest declines (Jan-April 2015 to Jan-April 2016) – in CDN $000s
exports1
Source: Trade Data Online.

On the winners side, Gypsum product exports are up (but in absolute terms by a fairly limited amount).  Aquaculture exports are up strongly by $35 million in the first four months.  Peanut butter exports are rolling along (snack food).  The value of seafood exports is up by $30 million.  The value of pulp million exports are up by $31 million.

International merchandise exports – Biggest increases (Jan-April 2015 to Jan-April 2016)  – in CDN $000s
exports2
Source: Trade Data Online.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Energy and mining export values down, gypsum, aquaculture and peanut butter up

Learning from Leicester City

I think there are lessons to be drawn from the Leicester City Foxes who recently won the 2015-16 English Premier League. The Foxes were 5,000 to 1 to win on the season’s opening day.

I can’t help but take a little jab at my Edmonton Oilers – a team I have followed since they joined the NHL in 1979 (I was 12 at the time).  In many country professional sports leagues (like the EPL) whole teams can be demoted if they don’t play good enough to remain in the top league.  I suspect if the NHL had that approach (i.e. the Oilers as a team would get demoted to a lower league) you would have far better hockey because teams would be extra vigilant to make sure they put a quality product on the ice.  These days teams like Toronto and Edmonton can languish in obscurity and still turn a nice profit for their owners (in fairness I have no idea if Edmonton has been profitable).

One of New Brunswick’s biggest challenges relates to how a small jurisdiction positions itself in a world that is more open and global than ever before.  Capital, talent and ideas are more mobile than at any time in our history (at least until the Trump Express hits the Whitehouse) and New Brunswick risks being left behind.

Leicester City shows that an innovative approach, a little luck as well as a version of the Tortoise and the Hare story can help elevate underdogs.

I am a little concerned that New Brunswick is too under the radar from a national economy perspective.  If Ontario had our province’s economic performance over the past eight years it would be an international issue.  When Alberta’s economic growth fell to zero (and slightly below), the nation’s media was awash in stories.   When NB has zero growth for seven straight years (on average) no one notices or they shrug their shoulders and say “that’s just New Brunswick”.

Why this matters is that we need the federal government to be concerned about NB’s economic trajectory and help where it can – in areas such as immigration, our share of national innovation funding, helping promote NB around the world using its global network of trade and investment officers, etc.

We need to attract national and international investment – like we have in the past – if we are too under the radar that becomes more difficult.

We need to attract a lot of talent in the coming years.  That too requires a focused effort.

The Economist magazine, after several articles extolling the virtues of Leicester City and drawing much broader lessons for the economy – has piece concluding that “underdogs are overrated”.

That too is an illustration of the challenges we face moving forward.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Learning from Leicester City

Brasileiros em New Brunswick: Will a wave of Brazilians help rebalance our demographics?

A YouTube channel that describes itself as “dedicated to Brazilians wish to one day live in Canada” recently featured an hour and 12 minute conversation with Sergio and Kaísa who recently moved to Moncton where Sergio is taking a course at the NBCC.  They would like to stay in Moncton after he finishes his course and the conversation was very positive on New Brunswick and Moncton – both Kaísa and Sergio could see themselves building their careers here.

The YouTube conversation has been viewed over 2,000 times (sorry, folks, its 100% in Portuguese – although they do talk about a new kind of Chiac – their word not mine) that is half English, half Portuguese.

Since Sergio and Kaísa’s  free promotional plug for New Brunswick the group’s Facebook site in Moncton has been pinged by numerous Brazilians asking more about New Brunswick and expressing an interest in moving here.

I think it would be kind of cool to attract more young Brazilians here – New Brunswick could use a little more samba.

I’ve taken to preparing quite a bit of Brazilian food – feijoada, feijao, farofa, pao de queijo, mousse de maracuja, etc.  It’s good.

But I do wonder about the cold winters.  Speaking from experience, most Brasileiros are not hardwired for 30 below winter days.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

Growth in the provincial workforce and GDP by Premier

Between 1987 and 1997, the years when Frank McKenna was Premier the provincial workforce expanded by 32,000 people and total employment increased by 29,800.  Real GDP grew by 11.3%.

Between 1999 and 2006, when Bernard Lord was Premier, the workforce expanded by 21,400 and total employment grew by 24,700.  Real GDP grew by 17.8%.

Between 2006 and 2010 when Shawn Graham was Premier the provincial workforce expanded by 10,400 and total employment by 7,700. Real GDP grew by 2.1%.

Between 2010 and 2014, during Premier Alward’s term, the provincial workforce shrunk by 1,300 and total employment dropped by 4,200. Real GDP declined by 0.7%.

Between 2014 and 2015, the provincial workforce has declined by 2,800 and total employment is down 2,100. We don’t know the final tally for 2015 GDP yet – we are expecting a marginally positive number but not outstanding.

I wonder how many people out there still don’t see a connection between the trajectory of the workforce and economic growth?

By the way, if I put up the national numbers you would see roughly the same correlation – the only difference is the workforce nationally has been growing rapidly in line roughly with GDP growth.  Between 2008 and 2015, New Brunswick’s workforce declined by 4,100.  The national workforce increased over the same timeframe by 1.16 million.

And most of the net growth was made up of immigrants. FYI.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

Are women or men more at risk from the coming automated economy?

After a Davos conversation there have been a number of stories recently about which gender is most ask risk from the coming automated economy – driverless cars, robots, etc.  It’s an interesting conversation.  I took at look at the occupational differences between women and men in New Brunswick to add a little local context to this debate.  Most of the findings are not overly surprising but there are a few eyebrow raisers.

For a methodology, I took the share of employment for males and females and then compared the the two with male employment as the base (= 1.00).  Simply, anything less than 1.00 means that the female workforce has a lower share compared to men and anything above means they have a higher share.

The table below shows the highest level summary for the top level NOC codes 1-9.  As would be expected, females have fewer people in management relative to men (36% less) but they have 2.6 times as many working in business, finance and admin occupations.  There are 4.4 times as many females working in health occupations compared to men.  On the opposite end of the spectrum, there are 70% fewer females working in natural and applied sciences occupations, almost none in trades and transportation, very few in natural resources occupations and less than half – relatively speaking – in manufacturing occupations.


chart


The more detailed breakdown (link below) reveals some interesting findings at the more granular level.  There are significantly more females in senior management roles in health, education and social services compared to men; 33% more financial managers, 95% more HR managers, 43% more banking, credit and investment managers, and three times as many managers in health care.

Females are more heavily employed in administrative occupations (three times as many compared to men).  The main outlier – there are 61 times as many females working as medical admin. assistants than men.

There are far fewer women in science-based occupations except biologists where there are 15% more women compared to men.  There are 84% fewer female civil, mechanical, electrical and chemical engineers; 85% fewer computer engineers; 59% fewer architects and 77% fewer computer programmers compared to men.

Women kick arse in health care – except for NOC 311 Physicians, dentists and veterinarians – where there are 27% fewer females than males.  However, there are 35% more female veterinarians, more optometrists, 73% more pharmacists, nearly six times as many females in therapy-based occupations, 5.5 times as many in med. tech occupations.

There are slightly fewer female university professors (21% fewer) but more college instructors (+27%).  There are more than 3 times as many teachers.

There are 22% fewer female lawyers compared to men and 70% fewer police officers.

There are 66% more female bartenders – who knew?

There are very few women working in the trades and transportation occupations. 96% fewer working as machinists or related workers.  98% fewer plumbers, 98% fewer carpenters, 96% fewer heavy equipment operators.

There are far fewer females working in virtually all natural resource-based occupations except nursery workers (67% more) and harvesting labourers (83% more).  More women work in fish plant occupations (12% more) and labourers in fish and seafood processing (75% more).

Here is the full review of 600+ occupations for New Brunswick.  Some interesting stuff in there.

I guess I don’t really address the subject of this blog but I’ll let you draw your own conclusions.

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Are women or men more at risk from the coming automated economy?

Redux: Does labour follow capital or vice versa?

Should New Brunswick focus more on trying to attract jobs or on growing the population?An interesting new study out of Indiana has important implications for economic development in New Brunswick.

The researchers looked at whether or not job growth (efforts to foster more jobs) lead to population growth or did having a growing population foster new job growth.

They found that “in the 1970s people followed jobs, but by the 2000s they had stopped.”  If the economy was going to grow the workers had to be in place.  In other words, the researchers conclude that communities need to be great places to live and attract people and the jobs will come rather than trying to attract jobs to places with tight and shrinking labour markets.

That sounds a lot like New Brunswick these days.

I have been saying all along that there are some jobs that will attract labour.  Think Fort McMurray.  Sectors such as mining tend to be a magnet for workers.  But most industries are not like that.   If there isn’t a pool of labour, over time investment and jobs will decline. I would not say this is a universal fact but for places such New Brunswick (and apparently Indiana) this is the case.

The study goes further and suggests the tax incentives used to lure jobs to the state were not well spent and the money should have been used to improve the quality of place and boost population.

I wouldn’t be as stark on this point.

I still believe there is an important role for communities and governments to expose firms to potential investment opportunities in their areas.  For example, if a small community has enough local demand for a dentist and there are not a pile of dentists lining up to come, the community should build a business case and use it to convince a dentist to locate there.  Likewise if a province has opportunities in shellfish aquaculture, mining, blueberries, etc.  it should package and promote those opportunities to investors. If it has gateway infrastructure – roads, ports, airports with opportunities – it should promote these opportunities to investors. If it has low cost energy it should promote this benefit to industry.

If other jurisdictions are offering tax breaks or other forms of subsidy, we may well need to play some version of that game but I believe if we are ‘selling’ real opportunities with tangible value to investors, incentives will be less important.

The idea of trying to lure firms to New Brunswick with cash incentives even as the labour market is shrinking is increasingly problematic.  Even if the firms move in they may take workers from existing employers who will then not be able to fill the vacancies.

New Brunswick needs to focus on intentionally growing its population – it’s working age population.  This is foundational to ensuring investment and sustained GDP growth is in our future.

 

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

Manitoba and immigration: An interesting case study

The Manitoba example is an interesting one for us to consider as we think more deeply about immigration and the labour market.  Even though Manitoba has no oil and gas industry and only a fairly small mining sector (less that 3% of total GDP) its economy grew robustly between 2006 and 2014.  Not to the level of Saskatchewan or Alberta mind you but still the size of the economy (real GDP) swelled by 20%.  New Brunswick, by contrast, saw its total economy grow by only 2% over the same period.

What is interesting is the drivers of economic growth.  In Manitoba, manufacturing GDP increased by 14% while decreasing 11% in New Brunswick.  Transportation and warehousing GDP up by 12% in Manitoba but down 3% in New Brunswick. The administration and support services sector (where many contact centre jobs are classified) grew its GDP by 8% in Manitoba while declining by 7% in New Brunswick.

If you look at the ‘public sectors’ in comparison to overall GDP growth you see an interesting trend too.  Health care GDP and public administration GDP grew strongly in Manitoba but less than the rate of overall economic growth.  In New Brunswick, by contrast, health care GDP grew five times faster than overall GDP and public administration GDP grew six times.
imms

 

But what is really interesting is the correlation between growing industries and immigration.  Manitoba, a province only slightly larger than New Brunswick, attracted more than 8 times as many immigrants between 2001 and 2011 (defined as those living in the province in 2011 that arrived in Canada between 2001 and 2011).

But when it comes to the occupations that support export-oriented industries, the multiples go through the roof.  Of the more than 18,000 New Brunswickers who worked in manufacturing-related occupations (NOC 9) in 2011, only 175 were recent immigrants (0.9%).  In Manitoba, it was 5,515 (one in five of every workers).  Manitoba attracted 31.5 times as many workers in NOC 9 compared to New Brunswick over the period.

imms2

It’s clear that Manitoba has been attracting immigrants for years to support economic growth.

One final point.  Between 2001 and 2011, Manitoba’s employed workforce expanded by 62,000 people.  46,000 of the workers were recent immigrants.

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Manitoba and immigration: An interesting case study

The size of NB’s workforce is smaller now than back in 2008. Only province to shrink.

New Brunswick saw an uptick in job creation in the last few months on 2015 and an overall real GDP growth rate (the final number is not in) of likely something above one percent.  That may not seem like much but compared to the average rate of zero since 2008 that is a good step forward.

A lot of folks  – me included – now believe the labour market is becoming the biggest drag on GDP growth potential in New Brunswick.  As you can see from the chart below we are the only province in Canada that has seen its labour force shrink since 2008.  Across Canada the number of people working or looking for work has increased by 1.16 million people.  In New Brunswick, it has shrunk by 4,000.


Growth/decline in the size of the labour force (% change 2008-2015)

lfs
Source: Statistics Canada CANSIM Table 282-0002.


 

There is a fairly strong correlation actually between labour force growth since 2008 and GDP growth.  NB has faired the worst among the provinces.  Nova Scotia has been only a little better and PEI has actually had the best GDP growth rate among the four Atlantic Provinces along with its 5.7% increase in the labour force.

How do we grow the labour force?  Either by encouraging more NBers to join or by attracting folks from outside the province or country to come in.  The labour force participation rate (the percentage of adults that are either looking for work or working) has actually gone down from 2008 to 2015.  This is mostly a function of age.  Only 11 percent of folks over the age of 65 are in the labour market (participating) and while that is up from 6.5% in 2008 there is some question about how many more in this age group will join the labour market.

Among those in the prime age group 25-54, 87% are in the labour market (in 2015). There is not likely much more opportunity to expand that group.

Expanding the labour market will be very important if we are to get the economy moving in the right direction.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

The importance of international investment into New Brunswick

Long time readers of this blog will know of my focus on positive investment flows as the underlying foundation for economic development.  Because we are a small province, etc. most of the savings accumulated in New Brunswick flows out of the province to fund economic development elsewhere. If you think about all the public pension monies (provincial and national) that are collected each year in New Brunswick they mostly flow outward for investment elsewhere and then flow back as needed to meet pension obligations.  The Canada Pension Plan, as one example, is investing in toll highways in Australia.  This also applies to private savings.  If you look at where your RRSPs are invested you will find very little if any investment in your home province with the exception of some indirect investment (i.e. if you have shares in a bank and that bank has branches in New Brunswick).

I’m not complaining about the outward investment flow.  Just like people and ideas – the global mobility of capital is now easier and safer than ever. It just puts an onus on us to ensure there is more than enough capital flowing back into New Brunswick in the form of investment in our firms and in economic projects across the province.

This investment can come in many forms.  Like the CPP example above, it can involve investors putting money into low risk publicly back infrastructure projects but more importantly it needs to flow into firms and into greenfield multinational investments in plant, equipment and IP in New Brunswick. Firms investing in the mining sector, manufacturing, professional services, IT, contact centres, etc. that are based on export markets (Canada and international) boost employment, GDP and tax revenue.

New Brunswick needs more of this investment.  While the interprovincial foreign investment flow data is very limited, we have good data at a national level.  Across Canada, foreign owned companies have been pumping in new investment, expanding employment and growing their footprint.  According to Statistics Canada, from 2010 to 2013, foreign majority-owned affiliates in Canada added more than 150,000 net new jobs between 2010 and 2013 including 20,000 in the mining sector (which has likely retrenched some since 2013), manufacturing (18,500), wholesale trade (26,000), professional services (20,500), administrative and support services (11,500) and accommodation and food services (23,000).  The figure below shows the percentage change in total employment by 2 digit NAICS code.

foreignowned

 

While we don’t have the NB data, it is fair to say that multinational investment is not rushing into the province these days.  The wholesale trade industry – adding 26,000 jobs from foreign majority-owned affiliates across Canada – has been shrinking in New Brunswick.   Manufacturing investment is way down. Mining GDP has been cut dramatically.  Even ICT GDP has been relatively flat in recent years.

So how do we encourage national and international investment?  Well, it can come through greenfield investment (i.e. a firm comes here and sets up a new operation to service national or international markets) or it can come through investments in NB firms (equity stakes, outright acquisitions, etc.)  which connect the NB firms into global supply chains and helps build international markets.  According to Statistics Canada, foreign majority-owned affiliates across Canada account for more than 50% of international merchandise exports.  While I can’t give you the NB share it is likely in the 10% range.

Why would international firms want to invest here?  We need to have a value proposition for investment.

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments